In re Ohio Criminal Sentencing Statutes Cases

Page 1174

847 N.E.2d 1174

109 Ohio St.3d 313

2006-Ohio-2109

In re OHIO CRIMINAL SENTENCING STATUTES CASES.

Supreme Court of Ohio.

Submitted April 25, 2006.

Decided May 3, 2006.

{¶ 1} The following dispositions of currently pending appeals and certified conflicts are hereby entered based on our decision in State v. Foster, 109 Ohio St.3d 1, 2006-Ohio-856, 845 N.E.2d 470.

MOYER, C.J., RESNICK, PFEIFER, LUNDBERG STRATTON, O'CONNOR, O'DONNELL and LANZINGER, JJ., concur.

I

{¶ 2} The judgments of the courts of appeals in the following cases are reversed, and the causes are remanded to the trial courts for resentencing. If propositions of law are noted, such reversals shall apply only to those portions of the judgments of the courts of appeals that are implicated by the applicable propositions of law:

{¶ 3} 2004-1259. State v. Taylor, Madison App. No. CA2003-07-025, 2004-Ohio-3171, 2004 WL 1373198.

{¶ 4} 2004-1561. State v. Blade, Cuyahoga App. No. 83796, 2004-Ohio-4486, 2004 WL 1902523. Proposition of Law No. II.

{¶ 5} 2004-1635. State v. Lett, Cuyahoga App. Nos. 83821 and 83822, 2004-Ohio-4094, 2004 WL 1753209. Proposition of Law No. VI of the appeal and Proposition of Law No. II of the cross-appeal.

{¶ 6} 2004-2074. State v. Sanders, Lake App. No. 2003-L-144, 2004-Ohio-5937, 2004 WL 2526405. Proposition of Law No. II.

{¶ 7} 2005-0046. State v. Wheeler, Washington App. No. 04CA1, 2004-Ohio-6598, 2004 WL 2827714. Proposition of Law No. II.

{¶ 8} 2005-0065. State v. Garrett, Clark App. No. 2003 CA 40, 2004-Ohio-6876, 2004 WL 2914968.

{¶ 9} 2005-0158. State v. Parsons, Ashtabula App. No. 2003-A-0030, 2004-Ohio-7237, 2004 WL 3090219. Proposition of Law No. I.

{¶ 10} 2005-0185. State v. Chewning, Clermont App. No. CA2004-01-002, 2004-Ohio-6661, 2004 WL 2849222. Proposition of Law No. III.

{¶ 11} 2005-0202. State v. Hartsock, Lucas App. No. L-03-1215, 2004-Ohio-6905, 2004 WL 2924327. Proposition of Law No. III. Lanzinger, J., not participating.

{¶ 12} 2005-0234. State v. Barnette, Mahoning App. No. 02 CA 65, 2004-Ohio-7211, 2004 WL 3090228 and 2005-Ohio-477, 2005 WL 293804. Proposition of Law III of the appeal.

{¶ 13} 2005-0241. State v. Love, Mahoning App. No. 03 MA 19, 2004-Ohio-7062, 2004 WL 2980343. Proposition of Law No. II.

{¶ 14} 2005-0257. State v. Morris, Guernsey App. No. 03 CA 29, 2004-Ohio-6988, 2004 WL 2955226.

{¶ 15} 2005-0258. State v. Hardie, Washington App. No. 04CA21, 2004-Ohio-7278, 2004 WL 3090197. Proposition of Law No. I.

{¶ 16} 2005-0284. State v. Hardie, Washington App. No. 04CA24, 2004-Ohio-7277, 2004 WL 3090247.

{¶ 17} 2005-0296. State v. Morales, Lake App. No. 2003-L-025, 2004-Ohio-7239, 2004 WL 3090188. Proposition of Law No. III.

{¶ 18} 2005-0316. State v. Curd, Lake App. No. 2003-L-030, 2004-Ohio-7222 2004 WL 3090211. Proposition of Law No. I.

{¶ 19} 2005-0339. State v. Ferguson, Hamilton App. No. C-040114, 2004-Ohio-7132, 2004 WL 3015093. Proposition of Law No. II.

{¶ 20} 2005-0371. State v. Rowles, Summit App. No. 22007, 2005-Ohio-14, 2005 WL 19440. Proposition of Law No. I.

{¶ 21} 2005-0374. State v. Walker, Hamilton App. No. C-040202.

{¶ 22} 2005-0380. State v. Jenkins, Summit App. No. 22008, 2005-Ohio-11, 2005 WL 19439. Proposition of Law No. II.

{¶ 23} 2005-0500. State v. Hall, Franklin App. No. 04AP-17, 2005-Ohio-335, 2005 WL 225312. Proposition of Law No. I.

{¶ 24} 2005-0535. State v. Murphy, Lake App. No. 2003-L-049, 2005-Ohio-412, 2005 WL 280357.

{¶ 25} 2005-0542. State v. Abdul-Mumin, Franklin App. Nos. 04AP-485 and 04AP-486, 2005-Ohio-522, 2005 WL 315062.

{¶ 26} 2005-0576. State v. Wilson, Washington App. No. 04CA18, 2005-Ohio-830, 2005 WL 459129. Proposition of Law No. I.

{¶ 27} 2005-0587. State v. Dinapoli, Lake App. No. 2003-L-169, 2005-Ohio-824, 2005 WL 449467. Proposition of Law No. I.

{¶ 28} 2005-0613. State v. Carson, Hamilton App. No. C-040042, 2005-Ohio-902, 2005 WL 497290. Proposition of Law No II.

{¶ 29} 2005-0614. State v. Bell, Hamilton App. No. C-040488. Proposition of Law No. II.

{¶ 30} 2005-0619. State v. Schaub, Lake App. No. 2003-L-091, 2005-Ohio-703, 2005 WL 407567.

{¶ 31} 2005-0622. State v. Battle, Franklin App. No. 03AP-1269, 2005-Ohio-707, 2005 WL 407572.

{¶ 32} 2005-0628. State v. Ashbrook, Stark App. No. 2004-CA-00109, 2005-Ohio-740, 2005 WL 428032. Proposition of Law No. III.

{¶ 33} 2005-0632. State v. Billingsley, Putnam App. No. 12-04-14.

{¶ 34} 2005-0633. State v. Billingsley, Putnam App. No. 11-04-21.

{¶ 35} 2005-0637. State v. Cockroft, Franklin App. No. 04AP-608, 2005-Ohio-748, 2005 WL 428573. Proposition of Law No. II.

{¶ 36} 2005-0643. State v. Moore, Allen App. No. 1-04-09, 2005-Ohio-676, 2005 WL 405706.

{¶ 37} 2005-0666. State v. Clifford, Paulding App. No. 11-04-06, 2005-Ohio-958, 2005 WL 517514.

{¶ 38} 2005-0688. State v. Sieng, Franklin App. No. 04AP-556, 2005-Ohio-1003, 2005 WL 555664. Proposition of Law No. VI.

{¶ 39} 2005-0709. State v. Le, Cuyahoga App. No. 84429, 2005-Ohio-881, 2005 WL 488378.

{¶ 40} 2005-0713. State v. Austin, Montgomery App. No. 20445, 2005-Ohio-1035, 2005 WL 567305. Proposition of Law No. II.

{¶ 41} 2005-0723. State v. Malloy, Allen App. No. 1-04-64, 2005-Ohio-961, 2005 WL 517469.

{¶ 42} 2005-0732. State v. Newsome, Ashtabula App. No. 2003-A-0069, 2005-Ohio-1104, 2005 WL 583789.

{¶ 43} 2005-0737. State v. Rupert, Lake App. No. 2003-L-154, 2005-Ohio-1098, 2005 WL 583796. Proposition of Law No. I {¶ 44} 2005-0745. State v. Black, Allen App. No. 1-04-83, 2005-Ohio-1253, 2005 WL 638688.

{¶ 45} 2005-0769. State v. Curlis, Wood App. No. WD-04-032, 2005-Ohio-1217, 2005 WL 635025.

{¶ 46} 2005-0772. State v. John, Lucas App. No. L-03-1261, 2005-Ohio-1218, 2005 WL 635026. Proposition of Law No. II of the cross-appeal.

{¶ 47} 2005-0789. State v. Scott, Cuyahoga App. No. 84844, 2005-Ohio-1192, 2005 WL 628524. Proposition of Law No. II.

{¶ 48} 2005-0809. State v. Goins, Mahoning App. No. 02CA68, 2005-Ohio-1439, 2005 WL 704865. Proposition of Law No. I.

{¶ 49} 2005-0826. State v. Ward, Washington App. No. 04CA25, 2005-Ohio-1580, 2005 WL 737578.

{¶ 50} 2005-0848. State v. Andrews, Cuyahoga App. No. 84137, 2005-Ohio-1161, 2005 WL 616081. Proposition of Law No. IV.

{¶ 51} 2005-0868. State v. Scarberry, Logan App. No. 8-04-32, 2005-Ohio-1425, 2005 WL 696829.

{¶ 52} 2005-0875. State v. Colvin, Franklin App. No. 04AP-421, 2005-Ohio-1448, 2005 WL 704818.

{¶ 53} 2005-0876. State v. Allen, Lake App. No. 2004-L-038, 2005-Ohio-1415, 2005 WL 694351.

{¶ 54} 2005-0890. State v. Hill, Cuyahoga App. No. 84683, 2005-Ohio-1311, 2005 WL 678120. Proposition of Law No. III.

{¶ 55} 2005-0903. State v. Burns, Summit App. No. 22198, 2005-Ohio-1459, 2005 WL 711927. Proposition of Law No. I.

{¶ 56} 2005-0906. State v. Worrell, Franklin App. No. 04AP-410, 2005-Ohio-1521, 2005 WL 736529. Proposition of Law No. II.

{¶ 57} 2005-0909. State v. Holt, Erie App. No. E-04-004, 2005-Ohio-1554, 2005 WL 737000. Proposition of Law No. I.

{¶ 58} 2005-0910. State v. Hyslop, Lucas App. No. L-03-1298, 2005-Ohio-1556, 2005 WL 736996.

{¶ 59} 2005-0917. State v. Rorie, Stark App. No. 2002CA00187, 2005-Ohio-1726, 2005 WL 845230.

{¶ 60} 2005-0954. State v. Whited, Washington App. No. 04CA31, 2005-Ohio-2224, 2005 WL 1048721.

{¶ 61} 2005-0966. State v. Wymer, Lucas App. No. L-03-1125, 2005-Ohio-1775, 2005 WL 859445.

{¶ 62} 2005-0983. State v. Harris, Fulton App. No. F-04-005, 2005-Ohio-1779, 2005 WL 859448. Proposition of Law No. III. The discretionary appeal as to Proposition of Law Nos. V and VI (previously held for the decision in 2004-1279 and 2004-1696, State v. Threatt) is dismissed as having been improvidently accepted.

{¶ 63} 2005-1020. State v. Daniels, Putnam App. No. 12-04-07, 2005-Ohio-1920, 2005 WL 941019. Proposition of Law No. II.

{¶ 64} 2005-1042. State v. Spellman, Geauga App. No. 2004-G-2565, 160 Ohio App.3d 718, 2005-Ohio-2065, 828 N.E.2d 695. Proposition of Law No. III.

{¶ 65} 2005-1051. State v. Beltowski, Lake App. Nos. 2003-L-126 and 2003-L-150, 2005-Ohio-2075, 2005 WL 1007191. Proposition of Law No. III.

{¶ 66} 2005-1056. State v. Bradford, Lake App. No. 2003-L-168, 2005-Ohio-2070, 2005 WL 1009821. Proposition of Law No. II.

{¶ 67} 2005-1117. State v. Todd, Butler App. No. CA2004-06-123, 2005-Ohio-2270, 2005 WL 1077179.

{¶ 68} 2005-1134. State v. Howard, Clark App. No. 2004CA29, 2005-Ohio-2237 2005 WL 1060621. Proposition of Law No. IV.

{¶ 69} 2005-1139. State v. Clifford, Paulding App. No. 11-04-18, 2005-Ohio-2357, 2005 WL 1131585. Proposition of Law No. I.

{¶ 70} 2005-1161. State v. Watkins, Allen App. No. 1-04-17, 2005-Ohio-2359, 2005 WL 1131576. Proposition of Law No. I.

{¶ 71} 2005-1164. State v. Farley, Butler App. No. CA2004-04-085, 2005-Ohio-2367, 2005 WL 1131745.

{¶ 72} 2005-1175. State v. Montgomery, Clermont App. No. CA2004-06-047, 2005-Ohio-2371, 2005 WL 1131734.

{¶ 73} 2005-1200. State v. Sebring, Butler App. No. CA2004-08-195.

{¶ 74} 2005-1207. State v. Krois, Hamilton App. No. C-040543.

{¶ 75} 2005-1242. State v. Calhoun, Butler App. No. CA2004-08-192.

{¶ 76} 2005-1249. State v. Fiedler, Lake App. No. 2003-L-190, 2005-Ohio-3388, 2005 WL 1538243.

{¶ 77} 2005-1250. State v. Semala, Lake App. No. 2003-L-128, 2005-Ohio-2653, 2005 WL 1272473.

{¶ 78} 2005-1303. State v. Mason, Butler App. Nos. CA2004-06-154 and CA2004-06-164, 2005-Ohio-2918, 2005 WL 1385221. Proposition of Law No. VII.

{¶ 79} 2005-1319. State v. Paynter, Muskingum App. No. CT2004-0015, 2005-Ohio-2911, 2005 WL 1384629. Proposition of Law Nos. III and IV.

{¶ 80} 2005-1321. State v. Coffeen, Butler App. No. CA2004-08-211.

{¶ 81} 2005-1324. State v. Langlois, Ashtabula App. No. 2003-A-0080, 2005-Ohio-2795, 2005 WL 1324724. Proposition of Law No. III.

{¶ 82} 2005-1343. State v. Satterwhite, Franklin App. Nos. 04AP-964 and 04AP-965, 2005-Ohio-2823, 2005 WL 1356445.

{¶ 83} 2005-1345. State v. Morris, Highland App. No. 04CA20, 2005-Ohio-2980, 2005 WL 1400033.

{¶ 84} 2005-1353. State v....