R. v G.T.D., 2017 ABCA 274

"...[1987] 1 S.C.R. 265; R. v. Harrison, 2009 SCC 34, [2009] 2 S.C.R. 494; R. v. Paterson, 2017 SCC 15, [2017] 1 S.C.R. 202; R. v. G.T.D., 2017 ABCA 274, 57 Alta. L.R. (6th) 213, rev’d 2018 SCC 7, [2018] 1 S.C.R. 220; R. v. Côté, 2011 SCC 46, [2011] 3 S.C.R. 215; R. v. Mian, 2014 SCC 54, [2014]..."

"...generally communicated in terms of, “you do not have to say anything”: PRPS Caution to Arrestee (Exhibit #18, para. 6); Regina v. G.T.D., 2017 ABCA 274, at para. 3 (affd 2018 SCC 7); Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, Code C Revised (Code of Practice for the detention, treatment and que..."

"...that the trial judge erred by failing to consider the systemic nature of the breach. As Veldhuis J.A. said in her dissent in R v G.T.D., 2017 ABCA 274, 355 CCC (3d) 431, which was affirmed at 2018 SCC 7, [2018] 1 SCR [85] Courts must take institutional or systemic Charter breaches seriously..."

"...is of some importance since an institutional or systemic Charter breach will be more serious than an isolated incident: R v GTD, 2017 ABCA 274 at para 82, per Veldhuis JA in dissent, aff’d in 2018 SCC 7; R v Ippak, 2018 NUCA 3 at paras 39-43. First, we note that the trial judge did not spec..."

"...(the Accused and AB clearly lived and travelled together over a period of 2 years). There was a “position of trust”: R. v G.T.D., 2017 ABCA 274 [G.T.D.]citing R v Brown, Highway, & Umpherville, 1992 ABCA 132 at paras 18-26. [482] In her final trial testimony after the two ERC calls were..."

"...Court of Appeal in Regina v Kelly 65 seized upon these diferences to impart diferent meanings. The Court noted the “subtle 62 R v GTD , 2017 ABCA 274 at paras 18, 77, rev’d on remedy 2018 SCC 7 at para 2 . All judges at both levels of court held that the question breached s 10(b). See also ..."

"...177 Grouse , R v , 2004 NSCA 108 .................................................. 336 GTD , R v , 2017 ABCA 274, rev’d 2018 SCC 7 ............................ 337, 369, 385 Guenter , R v , 2016 ONCA 572 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25, 31, 43, 47-48, 282, 36..."

"..., supra note 100 at para 67; R v Harlett , 2016 ONCA 248 at paras 40-45; R v Gonzales , supra note 95 at para 170; R v GDT , 2017 ABCA 274 at paras 80-93, Veldhuis JA, dissenting, rev’d 2018 SCC 7 substantially for the reasons of Veldhuis JA. © 2023 Emond Montgomery Publications. All Rights..."

"...OJ No 3335 (QL) (Sup Ct J) ............. 228 GC, R v, 2010 ONSC 115 ..................................................... 98 GDT, R v, 2017 ABCA 274, rev’d 2018 SCC 7 ................................. 50-51 Ghotra, R v, 2021 SCC 12 , af ’g 2020 ONCA 373 ............................... . 119..."

"...response to the charge. 117 See Chapter 9 for more information on s 10(a). 118 See Devries , supra note 109 at para 37. 119 See R v GTD , 2017 ABCA 274 at para 3, rev’d on diferent grounds 2018 SCC 7. © 2025 Emond Montgomery Publications. All Rights Reserved. 338 Detention, Arrest, and the ..."

"...Court of Appeal in Regina v Kelly 65 seized upon these diferences to impart diferent meanings. The Court noted the “subtle 62 R v GTD , 2017 ABCA 274 at paras 18, 77, rev’d on remedy 2018 SCC 7 at para 2 . All judges at both levels of court held that the question breached s 10(b). See also ..."

"...177 Grouse , R v , 2004 NSCA 108 .................................................. 336 GTD , R v , 2017 ABCA 274, rev’d 2018 SCC 7 ............................ 337, 369, 385 Guenter , R v , 2016 ONCA 572 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25, 31, 43, 47-48, 282, 36..."

"..., supra note 100 at para 67; R v Harlett , 2016 ONCA 248 at paras 40-45; R v Gonzales , supra note 95 at para 170; R v GDT , 2017 ABCA 274 at paras 80-93, Veldhuis JA, dissenting, rev’d 2018 SCC 7 substantially for the reasons of Veldhuis JA. © 2023 Emond Montgomery Publications. All Rights..."

"...OJ No 3335 (QL) (Sup Ct J) ............. 228 GC, R v, 2010 ONSC 115 ..................................................... 98 GDT, R v, 2017 ABCA 274, rev’d 2018 SCC 7 ................................. 50-51 Ghotra, R v, 2021 SCC 12 , af ’g 2020 ONCA 373 ............................... . 119..."

"...response to the charge. 117 See Chapter 9 for more information on s 10(a). 118 See Devries , supra note 109 at para 37. 119 See R v GTD , 2017 ABCA 274 at para 3, rev’d on diferent grounds 2018 SCC 7. © 2025 Emond Montgomery Publications. All Rights Reserved. 338 Detention, Arrest, and the ..."

"...[1987] 1 S.C.R. 265; R. v. Harrison, 2009 SCC 34, [2009] 2 S.C.R. 494; R. v. Paterson, 2017 SCC 15, [2017] 1 S.C.R. 202; R. v. G.T.D., 2017 ABCA 274, 57 Alta. L.R. (6th) 213, rev’d 2018 SCC 7, [2018] 1 S.C.R. 220; R. v. Côté, 2011 SCC 46, [2011] 3 S.C.R. 215; R. v. Mian, 2014 SCC 54, [2014]..."

"...generally communicated in terms of, “you do not have to say anything”: PRPS Caution to Arrestee (Exhibit #18, para. 6); Regina v. G.T.D., 2017 ABCA 274, at para. 3 (affd 2018 SCC 7); Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, Code C Revised (Code of Practice for the detention, treatment and que..."

"...that the trial judge erred by failing to consider the systemic nature of the breach. As Veldhuis J.A. said in her dissent in R v G.T.D., 2017 ABCA 274, 355 CCC (3d) 431, which was affirmed at 2018 SCC 7, [2018] 1 SCR [85] Courts must take institutional or systemic Charter breaches seriously..."

"...is of some importance since an institutional or systemic Charter breach will be more serious than an isolated incident: R v GTD, 2017 ABCA 274 at para 82, per Veldhuis JA in dissent, aff’d in 2018 SCC 7; R v Ippak, 2018 NUCA 3 at paras 39-43. First, we note that the trial judge did not spec..."

"...(the Accused and AB clearly lived and travelled together over a period of 2 years). There was a “position of trust”: R. v G.T.D., 2017 ABCA 274 [G.T.D.]citing R v Brown, Highway, & Umpherville, 1992 ABCA 132 at paras 18-26. [482] In her final trial testimony after the two ERC calls were..."