R. v. Ottenbreit (B.), 2016 ABPC 77

"...ABPC 169 at para 26 and R v Dean, 2017 ABPC 37 at para 26.[36] Defence counsel provided the Court with the decision of R v Ottenbreit, 2016 ABPC 77, in support of his position. This case deals with a pat-down search prior to the ASD demand. In the case before me, the police officer specific..."

"...means of administering the ASD test except by having Schwab sit in the rear of [the] police vehicle” (at para 49).[45] R v Ottenbreit, 2016 ABPC 77: Henderson PCJ (as he then was) proposed that courts first consider whether it was reasonably necessary to conduct the ASD test in the police v..."

"...Alberta Courts excluded the results of subsequent breath tests pursuant to s. 24(2) of the Charter. See: 1.   R. v. Ottenbreit 2016 ABPC 77 2.   R. v. Osoba [2015] AJ 1122 3.   R. v. Toupin 2016 ABPC 44 4.   R. V. Wondu 2014 CarswellAlta 2709 [12] ..."

"...admitted the ASD results. Three found no breach and admitted the ASD result. They are: a) R. v. Schwab, 2015 ABPC 180 b) R. v. Ottenbreit, 2016 ABPC 77 c) R. v. Toupin, 2016 ABPC 44 d) R. v. Whyte, 2016 ABPC 69 e) R. v. Kim, 2016 ABPC 9 f) R. v. Gish, Transcript September 10, 2015 g) R. v. ..."

"...ABPC 180R. v. Osoba, 2015 A.J. 1122R. v. Parker, 2016 ABPC 169 (which included a wide summary of similar issue cases)R. v. Ottenbreit, 2016 ABPC 77R. v. Toupin, 2016 ABPC 44R. v. Kim, 2016 ABPC 9[22] The similar Charter issue raised in those cases is whether, the peace officer having decide..."

"...v Kim, 2016 ABPC 9 R v Mann, 2004 SCC 52, [2004] 3 SCR 59, 324 NR 215, 241 DLR (4th) 214, 185 CCC (3d) 308, 21 CR (6th) 1 R v Ottenbreit, 2016 ABPC 77 R v Schwab, 2015 ABPC 180, 124 WCB (2d) 127, 22 CR (7th) 36, 83 MVR (6th) 283 R v So, 2014 ABCA 451, 9 Alta LR (6th) 382, 72 MVR (6th) 45 R ..."

"...v Kim, 2016 ABPC 9 R v Mann, 2004 SCC 52, [2004] 3 SCR 59, 324 NR 215, 241 DLR (4th) 214, 185 CCC (3d) 308, 21 CR (6th) 1 R v Ottenbreit, 2016 ABPC 77 R v Schwab, 2015 ABPC 180, 124 WCB (2d) 127, 22 CR (7th) 36, 83 MVR (6th) 283 R v So, 2014 ABCA 451, 9 Alta LR (6th) 382, 72 MVR (6th) 45 R ..."

"...ABPC 169 at para 26 and R v Dean, 2017 ABPC 37 at para 26.[36] Defence counsel provided the Court with the decision of R v Ottenbreit, 2016 ABPC 77, in support of his position. This case deals with a pat-down search prior to the ASD demand. In the case before me, the police officer specific..."

"...means of administering the ASD test except by having Schwab sit in the rear of [the] police vehicle” (at para 49).[45] R v Ottenbreit, 2016 ABPC 77: Henderson PCJ (as he then was) proposed that courts first consider whether it was reasonably necessary to conduct the ASD test in the police v..."

"...Alberta Courts excluded the results of subsequent breath tests pursuant to s. 24(2) of the Charter. See: 1.   R. v. Ottenbreit 2016 ABPC 77 2.   R. v. Osoba [2015] AJ 1122 3.   R. v. Toupin 2016 ABPC 44 4.   R. V. Wondu 2014 CarswellAlta 2709 [12] ..."

"...admitted the ASD results. Three found no breach and admitted the ASD result. They are: a) R. v. Schwab, 2015 ABPC 180 b) R. v. Ottenbreit, 2016 ABPC 77 c) R. v. Toupin, 2016 ABPC 44 d) R. v. Whyte, 2016 ABPC 69 e) R. v. Kim, 2016 ABPC 9 f) R. v. Gish, Transcript September 10, 2015 g) R. v. ..."

"...ABPC 180R. v. Osoba, 2015 A.J. 1122R. v. Parker, 2016 ABPC 169 (which included a wide summary of similar issue cases)R. v. Ottenbreit, 2016 ABPC 77R. v. Toupin, 2016 ABPC 44R. v. Kim, 2016 ABPC 9[22] The similar Charter issue raised in those cases is whether, the peace officer having decide..."