R v Sandoval-Barillas, 2017 ABCA 154

"...nothing about the proposed opinion which lifted it from the area of determinations reserved to the jury: compare R v Sandoval-Barillas, 2017 ABCA 154 at paras 50-55, 348 CCC (3d) 462; R v Suarez-Noa, 2017 ONCA 627 at paras 78-90, 350 CCC (3d) 267.[81] This ground of appeal must be dismissed..."

"...affirmed 2018 SCC 9, [2018] S.C.J. No. 9 (QL). [21] As pointed out in the context of circumstantial evidence in R v Sandoval-Barillas, 2017 ABCA 154 at para 35, 348 CCC (3d) 462 quoting from R v Ellard, 2008 BCCA 341 at para 62, 239 CCC (3d) 233, the question is not whether a conviction was..."

"...needs to be assessed more on reliability than on credibility—“[b]ut [the appellate court] does not re-try them”: R v Sandoval-Barillas, 2017 ABCA 154 at para 37; R v Cabrera, 2019 ABCA 184 at para 125, aff’d 2019 SCC 56;. As Chief Justice Fraser recently stated in Cabrera at para 122, “[a] ..."

"...2020 BCCA 277, leave to appeal to SCC refused, 39483 (25 March 2021); see also obiter dicta in Lawrence; R v Sandoval-Barillas, 2017 ABCA 154; and R v Ajise, 2018 ONCA 494).  On the other hand, there are also a number of such cases where courts have declined to apply the..."

"...should not provide content which is not properly the subject of expert evidence: see R v Sekhon, 2014 SCC 15, R v Sandoval-Barillas, 2017 ABCA 154. In my view Ms. Mwamburi’s testimony that a massage therapist would know if they made contact with a male client’s genitals and th..."

"...2 SCR 24 at 42 [ Abbey 1982 ]. 2 Abbey 1982 , ibid ; R v K , A , 1999 CanLII 3793 at paras 71, 73 (Ont CA) ; R v Sandoval‑Barillas , 2017 ABCA 154 at para 55, referencing R v Wiens , 2016 BCCA 34, leave to appeal to SCC refused, [2016] SCCA No 189. 3 White Burgess Langille Inman v Abbott an..."

"..., ibid at para 51. 492 Ibid at para 49; Mallory , supra note 483 at para 85; Van , supra note 483 at para 33; R v Sandoval‑Barillas , 2017 ABCA 154 at paras 71-72. 493 Van , ibid at para 33. 494 The provisions of the Canada Evidence Act have been interpreted to include electronic records. S..."

"...eyewitness identification, including, but not limited to, a reminder to the jury to carefully consider all of 171 R v Sandoval‑Barillas , 2017 ABCA 154 at para 62, referencing R v Clark , 2016 ABCA 72 at paras 48, 66-67; Frimpong , supra note 16 at paras 23-26; R v McIntosh , supra note 35;..."

"...137, 138 Sandhman , R v , 2009 CanLII 59151 (Sup Ct J) ...................................... 551 Sandoval‑Barillas , R v , 2017 ABCA 154 ....................... 82, 83, 92, 98, 118, 245, 640 Santhosh , R v , 2016 ONCA 731, (2016), 342 CCC (3d) 41 (Ont CA) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..."

"...2 SCR 24 at 42 [ Abbey 1982 ]. 2 Abbey 1982 , ibid ; R v K , A , 1999 CanLII 3793 at paras 71, 73 (Ont CA) ; R v Sandoval‑Barillas , 2017 ABCA 154 at para 55, referencing R v Wiens , 2016 BCCA 34, leave to appeal to SCC refused, [2016] SCCA No 189. 3 White Burgess Langille Inman v Abbott an..."

"..., ibid at para 51. 492 Ibid at para 49; Mallory , supra note 483 at para 85; Van , supra note 483 at para 33; R v Sandoval‑Barillas , 2017 ABCA 154 at paras 71-72. 493 Van , ibid at para 33. 494 The provisions of the Canada Evidence Act have been interpreted to include electronic records. S..."

"...eyewitness identification, including, but not limited to, a reminder to the jury to carefully consider all of 171 R v Sandoval‑Barillas , 2017 ABCA 154 at para 62, referencing R v Clark , 2016 ABCA 72 at paras 48, 66-67; Frimpong , supra note 16 at paras 23-26; R v McIntosh , supra note 35;..."

"...137, 138 Sandhman , R v , 2009 CanLII 59151 (Sup Ct J) ...................................... 551 Sandoval‑Barillas , R v , 2017 ABCA 154 ....................... 82, 83, 92, 98, 118, 245, 640 Santhosh , R v , 2016 ONCA 731, (2016), 342 CCC (3d) 41 (Ont CA) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..."

"...nothing about the proposed opinion which lifted it from the area of determinations reserved to the jury: compare R v Sandoval-Barillas, 2017 ABCA 154 at paras 50-55, 348 CCC (3d) 462; R v Suarez-Noa, 2017 ONCA 627 at paras 78-90, 350 CCC (3d) 267.[81] This ground of appeal must be dismissed..."

"...affirmed 2018 SCC 9, [2018] S.C.J. No. 9 (QL). [21] As pointed out in the context of circumstantial evidence in R v Sandoval-Barillas, 2017 ABCA 154 at para 35, 348 CCC (3d) 462 quoting from R v Ellard, 2008 BCCA 341 at para 62, 239 CCC (3d) 233, the question is not whether a conviction was..."

"...needs to be assessed more on reliability than on credibility—“[b]ut [the appellate court] does not re-try them”: R v Sandoval-Barillas, 2017 ABCA 154 at para 37; R v Cabrera, 2019 ABCA 184 at para 125, aff’d 2019 SCC 56;. As Chief Justice Fraser recently stated in Cabrera at para 122, “[a] ..."

"...2020 BCCA 277, leave to appeal to SCC refused, 39483 (25 March 2021); see also obiter dicta in Lawrence; R v Sandoval-Barillas, 2017 ABCA 154; and R v Ajise, 2018 ONCA 494).  On the other hand, there are also a number of such cases where courts have declined to apply the..."

"...should not provide content which is not properly the subject of expert evidence: see R v Sekhon, 2014 SCC 15, R v Sandoval-Barillas, 2017 ABCA 154. In my view Ms. Mwamburi’s testimony that a massage therapist would know if they made contact with a male client’s genitals and th..."