661
TABLE OF CASES
1784049 Ontario Lt d (cob Alpha Care Studio 45) v Toronto (City),
2010 ONSC 1204 .........................................................................................19 5
2054476 Ontario Inc v 514052 Ontario Ltd, [2006] OJ No 4383 (SCJ) ............. 192
413528 Ontario Ltd v 951 Wilson Avenue Inc (1989), 71 OR (2d) 40,
[1989] OJ No 2599 (HCJ), appeal to Div Ct quashed ...........................421, 42 2
A(LL) v Beharriell , [1995] 4 SCR 536, 103 CCC (3d) 92,
[1995] SCJ No 102 .......................................................................................16 4
Adams v Law S ociety of Alberta, 2000 A BCA 240 .............................................306
Agnes Secur ities Ltd v British Columbia (1976), 70 DLR (3d) 504,
31 CCC (2d) 154, [1976] BCJ No 1292 (SC) .................................................181
Ahmadoun v Ont ario (AG), 2012 ONSC 955 ............................................. 432, 608
Airst v Airs t (1998), 37 OR (3d) 654, 21 CPC (4th) 146,
[1998] OJ No 2615 (Gen Div) ......................................................................190
Aldrich v State, 296 S W3d 225 (Tex App 2009) ................................................ 454
AM v Ryan, [1997] 1 SCR 157, 143 DLR (4th) 1, 1997 CanLII 403 ................... 312
Amato v Welsh, 2013 ONCA 258 ................................................................107, 26 4
Arthur JS Hal l & Co v Simons, [2000] 3 All ER 673 (HL)............................84, 107
Ashburton (Lord) v Pape, [1913] 2 Ch 469 (CA) ............................................... 190
Bank of Montreal v D resler, 2002 NBCA 69 ...................................................... 310
Barton v Nova Scoti a (AG), 2014 NSSC 192 ...............................................456, 46 8
Batchelor v Pattison and M ackersy (1876), 3 R 914 (Sess) .................................10 4
Baumgartner v B aumgartner (1995), 122 DLR (4th) 542,
2 BCLR (3d) 126, 1995 CanLII 2354 (CA) ..................................................308
Beckham v Com monwealth, 248 SW3d 547 (Ky 2008) ....................................425
Bell v Smith, [1968] SCR 664, 68 DLR (2d) 751, [1968] SCJ No 46 .................. 17 8
ETHICS AND CR IMINAL L AW662
Bezzeg v Bez zeg (1994), 153 NBR (2d) 212, 33 CPC (3d) 95,
[1994] NBJ No 437 (QB) ..............................................................................308
Blank v Can ada (Minister of Justice), 2006 SCC 39 ...........................161, 16 2, 163
Bledsoe v Law So ciety of British Columbia (1984), 11 DLR
(4th) 280, 13 CCC (3d) 560, [1984] BCJ No 1514 (CA) ............................. 615
Booth v Huxter (1994), 16 OR (3d) 528, 111 DLR (4th) 111,
[1994] OJ No 52 (Div Ct)..................................................................... 313, 32 0
Boreta v Prim rose Drilling Ventures Ltd, 2010 ABQB 383 ................................ 19 5
Bourgeois v Bolen, 200 4 ABQB 35 ......................................................................201
Brass v Can ada, 2011 FC 1102 (Proth)............................................................... 190
British Columbi a (AG) v Christie, 2007 SCC 21 ................................................. 23
British Columbi a (AG) v Davies, 2009 BCCA 337, leave to
appeal to SCC refus ed, [2009] SCCA No 421 ..................................... 600, 601
British Columbi a (Auditor General) v Brit ish Columbia
(Ministr y of AG), 2013 BCSC 98 .................................................................226
British Columbi a (Securitie s Commission) v Branch,
[1995] 2 SCR 3, 97 CCC (3d) 505, 1995 CanLII 142 ..........................505, 507
Brookville C arriers Flatbed GP Inc v Blackjack
Transport Ltd, 20 08 NSCA 22 .......................................214, 274, 286, 287−88
Brown v Commonwealt h, 226 SW3d 74 (Ky 2007) ..................................... 32 , 354
Brown v Doe, 2 F3d 1236 (2d Cir 1993),
cert denied 510 US 1125 (1994) .................................................................. 442
Brownell v Browne ll (1909), 42 SCR 368, [1909] SCJ No 51 .............................632
Butler v United States , 414 A2d 844 (DC 1980) ................................................363
Calcraft v Guest , [1898] 1 QB 759 (CA) ............................................................. 190
Canada (Citizen ship and Immigration) v Harkat, 2014 SCC 37 ................610, 639
Canada (MNR) v Thorton, 2012 FC 1313 ..........................................................19 0
Canada (Pr ivacy Commissioner) v Blood Tribe
Department of He alth, 2008 SCC 44 ...........................158, 161, 164, 248, 248
Canada Southe rn Petroleum v Amoco Canada
Petroleum Co (1997), 193 AR 273, 144 DLR (4th) 30,
[1997] AJ No 193 (CA), leave to appeal to SCC refu sed,
[1997] SCCA No 162 .................................................................................... 310
Canada v Solosk y (1979), [1980] 1 SCR 821,
50 CCC (2d) 495, 1979 CanLII 9 ................................. 160, 161, 164, 247, 248
Canadia n Blood Services v Freeman, 2 010 ONSC 4885 .................................... 243
Canadia n National Railway Co v McKercher LLP,
2013 SCC 39.........................................................................................6, 23, 44,
118, 164, 177, 214, 264, 266, 269, 274, 275−76, 287, 289, 306, 314, 323, 373,
419, 5 46
Canadia noxy Chemic al Ltd v Canada (AG), [1999] 1 SCR 743,
133 CCC (3d) 426, 1999 CanLII 6 80 ..........................................................525
Celanese Ca nada Inc v Murray Demolition Corp, 200 6 SCC 36,
rev’g (2004), 73 OR (3d) 64, 244 DLR (4th) 33,
[2004] OJ No 3983 (CA) ......................................................................192 , 193
Table of Cases 663
Chan v Dyn asty Executive Suites Ltd, [2006] OTC 650,
30 CPC (6th) 270, [2006] OJ No 2877 (SCJ) ....................................... 192 , 193
Chapelstone Development s Inc v Canada, 2004 NBCA 96 ............................... 19 0
Chiefs of Ontar io v Ontario (2003), 63 OR (3d) 335,
[2003] OJ No 580 (SCJ) ............................................................................... 320
Children’s Aid Societ y of Algoma v DP, 2006 ONCJ 170 ....................................201
Clark v State, 261 SW2d 339 (Tex Crim App 1953) ..................................504, 508
Clutchette v Rushen, 770 F2d 1469 (9th Cir 1985) ............................ 510, 519, 531
College of Physicians of Br itish Columbia v British Columbia
(Information and Pr ivacy Commissioner), 2002 BCCA 665 ......................158
Commonwealth v Alder man, 437 A2d 36 (Pa Super 1981) ........................... 32, 35
Commonwealth v Dow ney, 65 Mass App Ct 547 (2006) ...................................209
Commonwealth v Jermy n, 620 A2d 1128 (Pa 1993), cert denied,
510 US 1049 (1994) ..................................................................................... 354
Commonwealth v Ma scitti, 534 A2d 524 (Pa Super 1987) ........................354 , 364
Commonwealth v Mitchel l, 438 Mass 535, 781 NE2d 1237 (2003) ......32, 35, 354,
355, 363, 364
Commonwealth v Sten hach, 514 A2d 114 (Pa Super 1986),
appeal denied 534 A 2d 769 (1987) ...................................... 506, 514, 519, 531
Consulate Ventures Inc v A mico Contracting
& Engineeri ng (1992) Inc, 2010 ONCA 788 ........................ 214, 27 1, 274, 286
Côté v Rancourt, 20 04 SCC 58 ............................................ 118, 121, 267, 277, 320
Cowles v Balac (2006), 83 OR (3d) 660, 273 DLR (4th)
596, 2006 CanLII 3 4916 (CA), leave to appeal t o SCC
refused, [2006] SCCA No 496 .................................................................... 380
Davies, Ward & Beck v B aker and McKenzie (1998),
40 OR (3d) 257, 164 DLR (4th) 423, [1998] OJ No 3284 (CA) ................... 310
DB v British Columbi a (Director of Chi ld, Family and
Community Ser vice), 2002 BCCA 55 ..........................................................340
Dean v Dean, 6 07 So 2d 494 (Fla Di st Ct App 1992).........................................506
Demarco v Ungaro (1979), 21 OR (2d) 673, 95 DLR (3d) 385,
[1979] OJ No 4011 (HCJ) ........................................................................91, 107
Descôteaux v Mier zwinski, [1982] 1 SCR 860,
70 CCC (2d) 385, 1982 CanLII 22 ................................................ 16 0−61, 16 7,
169, 190, 247, 248, 249
Detlor v Brantford (City), 2013 ONCA 560 ........................................................409
Directeur des pou rsuites criminelles et p énales et
Shérif de la Cha mbre criminelle et pénale, 2010 QCCS 2362,
leave to appeal to C A refused, [2010] JQ No 10775 (CA)........................... 183
Dunkley v R, [1994] UKPC 32 ...........................................................................546
Everingham v O ntario (1992), 8 OR (3d) 121, 88 DLR (4th) 755,
[1992] OJ No 304 (Div Ct) .................................................................. 377, 580
